Tensions within the organization increased over the issue of how to adjust European Lutheranism to life in the New World. “Neo-Lutherans” wanted to have closer ties with Methodists and Puritans in order to build a united front against Catholics, theologically confused revivalists, and infidels. “Old Lutherans,” represented by the Missouri and Wisconsin Synods, wanted to maintain strict loyalty to the Lutheran Confessions and ties to Germany and Scandinavia. Schmucker and other east coast Lutherans
Page 62